From 4e0559501ae457cc2a52b0154dae8c198eeec336 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: momentum dev Date: Mon, 14 Sep 2026 07:31:37 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] fix: stop boosting names because a headline already reported the move Three independent tests over 2026-08-01+, all negative: premarket news, any window 7.9% vs 8.6% ran >=50% ...controlling for PM range 11.3% vs 21.0% ran >=50% intraday arrival, hour-matched 16.8% vs 24.6% ran >=10% forward The feed explains it. Of 1,621 headlines delivered for screened names during sessions: 61.7% reactive roundups ("Why X Shares Are Trading Higher", "20 Stocks Moving In..."), 2.7% law-firm spam, and 0.9% genuine catalyst PRs. The wire reports the move after it happens, so a boost on "has a headline" buys the late stage of a run. 11 of the 14 biggest runners (up to +912%) had no coverage at all. Set NEWS_RANK_BOOST to 1.0 (neutral). This also neutralises the binary fallback restored in 9b4c8e5 -- correct in intent (a dead enrichment must not silently disable news ranking) but it handed a flat 2x to any unclassified headline, and 62% of them are lagging roundups. Deliberately unchanged: - the LLM path. catalyst_score = conviction * max(0, sentiment), so a roundup (type none, sentiment <= 0) scores 0 and earns nothing, while a real bullish catalyst still lifts. It targets the 0.9% correctly. - the dilution veto, which sinks confirmed offerings and is a separate, sound mechanism. - the enrichment-down alarm from 9b4c8e5. Also evaluated and NOT shipped: halt-resumption as a catalyst feature. It is by far the best signal in this universe -- a >=3min bar gap resuming >=2% up ran >=25% afterwards 40-47% of the time vs ~11-20% baseline, holding in every hour of the session. But a time-aware A/B of the armed set moved mean forward run only 27.09% -> 27.84% and 165 -> 173 runners per 725 slots, because gap x rvol already encodes it (a halting stock has high relative volume by definition). Same collapse premarket range showed: strong univariate, near-zero marginal. The ranking is saturated; selection is not where the remaining edge is. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01A2LepdJfPCfK5Q8uznjFBM --- deploy/docker/overrides.live.seed.env | 13 ++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 12 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/deploy/docker/overrides.live.seed.env b/deploy/docker/overrides.live.seed.env index 1f76856..32f0a4c 100644 --- a/deploy/docker/overrides.live.seed.env +++ b/deploy/docker/overrides.live.seed.env @@ -15,7 +15,18 @@ NEWS_ENRICH_INTERVAL_SECONDS=120 NEWS_ENRICH_LOOKBACK_HOURS=12 NEWS_FEEDS=prnewswire=https://www.prnewswire.com/rss/news-releases-list.rss,businesswire=https://feed.businesswire.com/rss/home/?rss=G1QFDERJXkJeGVtRWQ==,globenewswire=https://www.globenewswire.com/RssFeed/orgclass/1/feedTitle/GlobeNewswire%20-%20News%20about%20Public%20Companies NEWS_LOOKBACK_HOURS=8 -NEWS_RANK_BOOST=2.0 +# BLIND HEADLINE BOOST DISABLED (1.0 = neutral), 2026-09-14. Measured three ways +# over 2026-08-01+: premarket news 7.9% vs 8.6% ran >=50%; controlling for premarket +# range 11.3% vs 21.0%; and an hour-matched event study of intraday arrivals, 16.8% +# vs 24.6% ran >=10% forward. News arrival predicts LOWER forward returns, every time. +# The cause is the feed: of 1,621 headlines it delivered for screened names during +# sessions, 61.7% were reactive roundups ("Why X Shares Are Trading Higher") and 0.9% +# were genuine catalyst PRs. It reports the move after it happens, so boosting on it +# buys the late stage. The LLM path is UNAFFECTED and stays on: catalyst_score is +# conviction * max(0, sentiment), so a roundup scores 0 and earns no boost, while the +# dilution veto still sinks confirmed offerings. Only the blind "has a headline" 2x +# is removed. Restore by setting this to 2.0. +NEWS_RANK_BOOST=1.0 # Ollama lives on 11434 (the standard port). The stack pointed at 30068/4000 with # a model that was never pulled, so catalyst enrichment produced nothing from # 2026-08-03 to 2026-09-13 — silently, because enrich_recent_news reports failure